Monday 2 February 2009

Marsh at sporting crossroads

as posted here

2nd February 2009, 10:30 WST

Mitchell Marsh faces a dilemma.

A talented footballer who was part of the State under 18s program last year, Marsh also faces a bright future in cricket.

He will soon have to make a decision about which sport he intends to pursue.

Marsh underlined his potential in the summer game with a record-breaking double-century for Fremantle on Saturday that put his team into a dominant position against Gosnells.

Marsh passed Mark McPhee's club record of 202 not out when he hammered 208, including 26 fours and 9 sixes, to help his team to 9-386.

Gosnells lost one wicket in their four over reply and Fremantle are sure to push hard for an outright victory that would keep alive their slim finals hopes.

Marsh will also bat for the WA second XI in the match against Queensland starting at Allan Border Field in Brisbane tomorrow.

But one player who will not be involved in that game in Wanneroo’s prolific No.3 Gary Dixon, the leading Retravision Shield runscorer this season, who refused the invitation to play because he intends to play baseball next year.

Dixon has scored 819 runs this season and is the favourite to win the Olly Cooley Medal as the champion club cricketer.

But he managed only 11 in Wanneroo’s paltry 99 as Willetton all-rounder Matt Johnston claimed a career-best 6-37 while the competition’s leading wicket-taker Chris Lagana, who had 31 before the round, picked up 4-30.

Warriors all-rounder David Bandy, who suffered a horrific head injury after being struck in the head during the Sheffield Shield match at the MCG before Christmas, made his comeback when Scarborough dismissed South Perth for 266 at Richardson Park.

Bandy was given the all-clear to resume late last week but did not bowl on Saturday. Ty Hopes and Theo Doropoulos each claimed three wickets while Hugh Brown top-scored with 76.

The race for the finals remains intense with seventh-placed Claremont-Nedlands in trouble against Rockingham-Mandurah and University (eighth) in a tight tussle with Perth.

Subiaco-Floreat are hanging on desperately to sixth spot and could strengthen their position after a strong display against Midland-Guildford.

Claremont were dismissed for 201 and Corey Whisson has helped bat Rockingham into favouritism at 2-79.

And after Uni were dismissed for 191, a century stand between Jim Cameron and Mark Penter preceding a collapse of 8-61 as Ross Scali claimed 6-42, Perth reached 1-24 before a thunderstorm stopped play.

Subi reached 0-45 after dismissing last-placed Midland for 211 while top team Melville knocked over third-placed Bayswater-Morley for 209 with veteran Steve Russell claiming 6-58.

Scorecards

Wanneroo v Willetton

Wanneroo
First Innings
Charles c O’Connell b Lagana 1
Richards b Lagana 8
Dixon b Johnston 11
Fairchild b Johnston 4
Fawcett c Elliot b Lagana 18
Delborrello c O’Connell b Johnston 13
Warren c Mason b Johnston 23
Atkinson GT c Elliot b Johnston 4
Atkinson GS c Mason b Lagana 2
Quelch c Smith b Johnston 3
Henry not out 2
Sundries: 10
Total: 99
Fall: 5, 18, 26, 26, 58, 62, 73, 88, 90
Bowling: Lagana 18-6-30-4, Ball 7-0-21-0, Johnston 14.2-3-37-6, Hall 3-2-2-0, Elliot 1-0-1-0

Willetton
First Innings
Elliot c Fairchild b Quelch 13
Smith b Atkinson GS 31
Brennan c Dixon b Quelch 17
O’Connell b Atkinson GS 20
Johnston lbw Atkinson GS 7
Silvey not out 6
Mason c Henry b Warren 4
Sundries: 1
Total: 6-99
Fall: 16, 34, 82, 83, 90, 99
Bowling: Quelch 12-3-37-2, Atkinson GS 13-5-23-3, Warren 10.4-0-26-1, Fairchild 4-0-13-0


Gosnells v Fremantle

Fremantle
First Innings
Aslett b Duffield 0
Milton c Upton b Abbott 0
Creevey c Norwood b Jenkins 15
Ervine lbw Abbott 72
Marsh c Duffield b Rees 208
Smith c Upton b Jenkins 17
Coulter-Nile b Duffield 10
Beaumont b Jenkins 29
Miles c Upton b Rees 10
Heath not out 0
Sundries: 25
Total: 9-386 decl
Fall: 0, 0, 60, 137, 176, 201, 309, 385, 386
Bowling: Duffield 23-5-110-2, Abbott 14-3-48-2, Jenkins 18-2-118-3, Horton 4-0-28-0, Turner 7-0-37-0, Norwood 3-0-21-0, Rees 1.2-0-6-2

Gosnells
First Innings
Rees run out 1
Bland not out 9
Turner not out 3
Sundries: 1
Total: 1-14
Fall: 1
Bowling: Heath 1-0-1-0, Coulter-Nile 1-0-7-0, Beaumont 1-0-1-0, Ervine 1-0-4-0


Joondalup v Mt Lawley

Joondalup
First Innings
Newnham c Brownlie b Davis P 0
Swart c Rakich b Palladino 18
Campbell c Walshaw b Kelly 93
Howell c Meredith b Armstrong 39
Richards lbw Kelly 10
Boyland run out 27
Griggs b Kelly 11
Wylie c Beaton b Armstrong 0
Sprague c Davis G b Kelly 23
D’Cruz c Walshaw b Palladino 26
Brett not out 8
Sundries: 20
Total: 275
Fall: 0, 112, 126, 144, 190, 195, 195, 235, 240, 275
Bowling: Davis P 20-6-53-1, Armstrong 11-2-59-2, Palladino 21.3-5-49-2, Walshaw 5-0-39-0, Kelly 20-10-47-4, Davis G 6-0-21-0


Melville v Bayswater-Morley

Bayswater-Morley
First Innings
Morgan lbw Russell 13
Davis lbw Russell 33
Birrell c Terry b Gillies 36
Adams lbw Russell 0
Phillimore c Russell b Platel 32
Robb run out 3
Thistle c Scollay b Russell 48
Barr not out 24
Wright c Terry b Russell 3
Daniels c Pitcher b Scollay 11
Francis c Gillies b Russell 3
Sundries: 3
Total: 209
Fall: 37, 48, 48, 93, 98, 143, 174, 188, 205, 209
Bowling: Gillies 19-4-36-1, Platel 15-2-50-1, Kerr-Sheppard 8-2-22-0, Russell 21-8-58-6, Scollay 10-0-43-1

Melville
First Innings
Meuleman not out 26
Towers not out 10
Sundries: 10
Total: 0-46
Fall:
Bowling: Francis 5-0-14-0, Thistle 3-0-23-0, Wright 2-0-4-0


Perth v University

University
First Innings
Vincec c Walters b Scali 4
Cameron A c Moir b Scali 11
Penter M lbw Yardy 50
Cameron J c Yardy b Scali 57
Barratt b Scali 14
Smith c Paterson b Scali 3
Hogg c Moir b Wilkinson 10
Molinari c Snadden b Nelson 32
Marshall c Walters b Scali 3
Evans lbw Wilkinson 0
Penter A not out 0
Sundries: 7
Total: 191
Fall: 14, 24, 126, 140, 145, 146, 174, 183, 184
Bowling: Keenan 13-4-19-0, Scali 21-5-42-6, Wilkinson 12-1-30-2, Nicholas 7-1-31-0, Walters 3-0-14-0, Nelson 6.1-0-24-1, Yardy 11-1-28-1

Perth
First Innings
Yardy not out 15
Barranca c Marshall b Evans 7
Snadden not out 2
Sundries: 0
Total: 1-24
Fall: 13
Bowling: Evans 4-1-9-1, Molinari 4-1-15-0


Rockingham-Mandurah v Claremont-Nedlands

Claremont-Nedlands
First Innings
King lbw Sarsero 1
Rees lbw Parsons 3
Allenby lbw Sarsero 20
Mason c Whisson b Parsons 57
Brabazon c Whiteman b Loveridge 5
Robertson c Whisson b Parsons 32
Clements c Whiteman b Parsons 0
Kelly not out 37
Donaldson c Whiteman b Loveridge 28
Rosario c Whiteman b Sarsero 13
McKay c Parsons b Sarsero 0
Sundries: 5
Total: 201
Bowling: Parsons 11-3-46-4, Sarsero 14.1-3-35-4, Loveridge 9-1-40-2, Heal 20-3-53-0, Senz 6-0-26-0

Rockingham-Mandurah
First Innings
Whisson not out 30
Sutton lbw McKay 37
Senz c King b Rosario 4
Sundries: 8
Total: 2-79
Fall: 69, 79
Bowling: Rosario 5-3-10-1, Kelly 5-1-16-0, Donaldson 4-0-17-0, Allenby 6-3-14-0, McKay 5-1-16-1


Subiaco-Floreat v Midland-Guildford

Midland-Guildford
First Innings
Corcoran c Lilly b Branston 16
Worthington run out 11
Sadler lbw Lilly 1
Blight b Lilly 32
Del Prete b Willey 16
Jose c Malajczuk b Branston 23
Jones b Branston 0
Crosswell c Glew b Monteleone 61
Crawford c Lilly b Hansberry 31
Baker lbw Monteleone 3
Stein not out 7
Sundries: 10
Total: 211
Fall: 22, 23, 33, 58, 103, 106, 116, 174, 188, 211
Bowling: Branston 15-3-59-3, Lilly 11-2-23-2, Willey 8-3-21-1, Bolton 6-1-22-0, Hansberry 20-4-53-1, Monteleone 15.1-3-30-2

Subiaco-Floreat
First Innings
Bolton not out 26
Malajczuk not out 18
Sundries: 1
Total: 0-45
Fall:
Bowling: Worthington 4-0-10-0, Stein 6-0-22-0, Crosswell 4-2-12-0, Sadler 2-1-1-0

PERTH
JOHN TOWNSEND

as posted here

Wednesday 28 January 2009

Langer spat as finals race comes to the boil

as posted here

28th January 2009, 12:30 WST

The race for the Retravision Shield finals has started to heat up with just three rounds of qualifying fixtures to go.

Four teams are within 1.25 points of sixth-placed Subiaco-Floreat.

Second innings bonus points - with every run worth 0.01 points and every wicket worth 0.2 - could be crucial as

Claremont-Nedlands, University and Wanneroo try to force their way into the top six.

Melville continue to dominate the competition after a crushing victory over third-placed Willetton sent the losers crashing.

Adam Voges completed a fine double with 3-11 and 74 preparing him for WA's important matches in the next month.

Scarborough also got back into the winner's circle when they put an end to Rockingham-Mandurah's finals hopes.

Justin Coetzee produced his third ton of the season while leg-spinner Ty Hopes claimed 4-25. But most excitement came in Justin Langer's sole over in the middle.

The former Test star had a verbal altercation with veteran Joe Sarsero, thrashed two fours and two sixes and was caught on the boundary in his first league match of the season.

University continued their advance under new captain Josh Mangan by accounting for Subiaco-Floreat in the inaugural Paul Nicholls Shield match.

The former State player captained and was on the committee at both clubs but died last week after a long battle with cancer.

Uni allrounder James Cameron put in a claim for a WA second XI berth with a powerful century in Uni's run chase after Subi were kept to 177 with Patrick Molinari (3-25) and Mangan (3-20) bowling superbly.

Gary Dixon is another player who should have come to the attention of the State selectors after producing his fourth century for Wanneroo this season.

Dixon crossed 800 runs for the season and will challenge Darrin Ramshaw's 20-yearold club season record of 856. His even 100 took Wanneroo to 250 in reply to cellar-dwellers Midland's 159.

Baywater-Morley moved into third place after State captain Marcus North's 87 helped them account for Gosnells.

But the Bears face top two clubs Melville and Scarborough in the next two rounds and will have to work hard to hang on to their place.

Scorecards
Willetton v Melville
Willetton
First Innings
Elliot c Lillis b Platel 24
Smith b Platel 14
Johnson c&b Russell 13
O'Connell run out 4
Brennan c Greig b Russell 10
Silvey b Russell 2
Mason c Porter b Voges 1
Bond not out 27
Lagana c Russell b Voges 3
Ball c Lillis b Voges 0
Hall b Gillies 0
Sundries: 7
Total: 105
Fall: 27, 50, 54, 72, 74, 75, 75, 86, 90, 105
Bowling: Porter 6-1-30-0, Platel 10-4-26-2, Gillies 5.5-2-14-1, Voges 10-5-11-3, Russell 10-2-22-3

Melville
First Innings
Meuleman c Brennan b Johnston 31
Towers c Elliot b Hall 22
Voges lbw Lagana 74
Porter c Bond b Silvey 42
Vince c Johnston b O'Connell 17
Scollay c Smith b Silvey 4
Russell not out 45
Gillies c Smith b Ball 15
Greig not out 6
Sundries: 12
Total: 7-268
Fall: 50, 64, 157, 194, 199, 203, 232
Bowling: Lagana 10-1-51-1, Ball 8-1-38-1, Johnston 7-0-33-1, Hall 8-2-36-1, O'Connell 9-1-62-1, Silvey 8-1-44-2
Melville won

Baywater-Morley v Gosnells
Gosnells
First Innings
Rees c Robb b Francis 61
Horton c Robb b Wright 22
Gauber lbw Barnes 4
Pomersbach lbw Barnes 20
Norwood c North b Thistle 14
Upton c Robb b Francis 2
Bailey b Adams 7
Abbott c Francis b North 10
Turner c Robb b Morgan 10
Townsend st Robb b Morgan 4
Jenkins not out 1
Sundries: 6
Total: 161
Bowling: Thistle 7-0-16-1, Francis 10-0-36-2, Barnes 10-1-36-2, Wright 9-0-24-1, North 10-0-41-1, Adams 1-0-2-1, Morgan 1.3-0-5-2

Bayswater-Morley
First Innings
Robb c Upton b Abbott 9
Davis c Horton b Pomersbach 45
Birrell st Upton b Horton 52
North b Abbott 87
Phillimore c townsend b Horton 10
Thistle c&b Pomersbach 15
Morgan c Townsend b Abbott 0
Adams not out 8
Wright c Abbott b Pomersbach 6
Francis b Abbott 15
Barnes not out 2
Sundries: 15
Total: 9-264
Fall: 39, 91, 182, 212, 224, 224, 229, 240, 255
Bowling: Townsend 10-0-43-0, Abbott 9-1-58-4, Jenkins 10-1-41-0, Pomersbach 9-0-56-3, Turner 4-0-23-0, Horton 8-0-38-2
Bayswater-Morley won

Claremont-Nedlands v Perth
Perth
First Innings
Yardy c Brabazon b Kelly 22
Barranca b Kelly 38
Walters st King b McKay 18
Nicholas c Roberts b McKay 37
Ronchi c McKay b Roberts 36
Paterson not out 16
Moir not out 11
Sundries: 7
Total: 5-185
Fall: 62, 67, 92, 154, 165
Bowling: Allenby 7-1-15-0, Rosario 10-0-43-0, Kelly 10-1-32-2, Robinson 4-0-11-0, McKay 10-0-32-2, Roberts 3-0-26-1, Mason 5-0-18-0, Brabazon 1-0-6-0
Claremont-Nedlands

First Innings
Rees c Nicholas b Keenan 4
Robinson run out 37
Allenby c Moir b Walters 28
Mason c Barranca b Walters 4
Brabazon c Moir b Nicholas 3
King c McAuliffe b Yardy 19
Clements st Moir b Yardy 3
Roberts b Nelson 12
Kelly c Keenan b Nicholas 24
Rosario not out 25
McKay not out 6
Sundries: 14
Total: 9-178
Fall: 6, 56, 63, 76, 80, 88, 118, 120
Bowling: Keenan 10-1-39-1, Scali 8-0-37-0, Walters 7-1-22-2, Nicholas 10-1-37-2, Yardy 10-1-25-2, Nelson 5-1-15-1
Perth won

Fremantle v Joondalup
Joondalup
First Innings
Swart lbw Muchall 27
Newnham c Smith b Heath 8
Howell lbw Dorey 1
Richards run out 115
Boyland b Coulter-Nile 4
Griggs not out 52
Tomlinson not out 6
Sundries: 21
Total: 5-234
Fall: 12, 13, 68, 110, 213
Bowling: Heath 10-1-41-1, Dorey 5-1-24-1, Muchall 10-0-63-1, Beaumont 10-0-61-0, Coulter-Nile 4-1-12-1, Simmons 10-0-28-0, Smith 1-0-3-0

Fremantle
First Innings
Shuttleworth R lbw Boyland 0
Simmons c Swart b Boyland 11
Milton c Wiley b Brett 35
Marsh lbw Boyland 0
Dorey c Brett b Swart 86
Smith lbw Boyland 16
Muchall c Newnham b Boyland 22
Coulter-Nile run out 11
Shuttleworth S not out 13
Beaumont b Swart 6
Heath lbw Boyland 1
Sundries: 20
Total: 221
Fall: 0, 28, 28, 78, 154, 172, 192, 212, 218, 221
Bowling: Boyland 9.2-0-42-6, Leach 7-0-32-0, D'Cruz 8-1-31-0, Brett 7-0-29-1, Richards 4-0-20-0, Howell 5-0-22-0, Swart 9-0-41-2
Joondalup won

Midland-Guildford v Wanneroo
Midland-Guildford
First Innings
Worthington c Henry b Atkinson GS 6
Corcoran c Fawcett b Warren 20
Sadler lbw Fairchild 41
O'Connor c&b Warren 3
Del Prete c Fairchild b Warren 9
Jose c Fawcett b Fairchild 20
Jones not out 35
Crosswell run out 9
Crawford run out 1
Baker not out 4
Sundries: 11
Total: 8-159
Fall: 22, 47, 59, 79, 88, 133, 149, 151
Bowling: Quelch 10-0-35-0, Atkinson GS 10-2-24-1, Warren 10-0-30-3, Fawcett 6-0-19-0, Fairchild 8-1-25-2, Atkinson GT 6-0-25-0

Wanneroo
First Innings
Charles c Worthington b Crawford 0
Richards c Jones b Stein 31
Dixon c Worthington b Stein 100
Fairchild lbw Stein 0
Fawcett c Sadler b Baker 28
Del Borello run out 12
Warren c Corcoran b Sadler 28
Atkinson GT c Jose b Stein 0
Henry c Sadler b Baker 16
Atkinson GS not out 21
Quelch c Sadler b Baker 1
Sundries: 13
Total: 250
Fall: 0, 54, 54, 107, 128, 203, 205, 206, 246, 250
Bowling: Crawford 6-0-35-1, Stein 10-1-49-4, Crosswell 10-0-46-0, Baker 9-0-46-3, Worthington 3-0-8-0, Sadler 10-0-62-1
Wanneroo won

Mt Lawley v South Perth
Mt Lawley
First Innings
Meredith c Brown b Edmondson 49
Beaton lbw b Powis 46
Brownlie c Cartwright b O’Shea 72
Rakich lbw b O’Shea 7
Walshaw c & b O’Shea 0
Davis G c Allen b O’Shea 8
Deering c Allen b Thompson 9
Davis P not out 31
Kelly not out 19
Sundries: 12
Total: 7-253
Fall: 71, 136, 158, 158, 166, 182, 223
Bowling: Edmondson 10-1-66-1, Thompson 10-1-34-1, Guthridge 10-0-47-0, Powis 10-1-48-1, O’Shea 10-0-54-3

South Perth
First Innings
O’Shea b Davis P 0
Brunner c Meredith b Armstrong 0
Brown c Rakich b Davis P 78
Hood c Brownlie b Kelly 42
Powis c Rakich b Kelly 1
Gardiner lbw b Davis P 1
Cartwright c & b Walshaw 39
Allan run out 37
Thompson b Davis G 5
Edmondson c Walshaw b Kelly 12
Guthridge not out 1
Sundries: 15
Total: 231
Fall: 0, 2, 128, 130, 131, 133, 196, 215, 227, 231
Bowling: Davis P 10-0-42-3, Armstrong 9-1-35-1, Palladino 10-0-46-0, Walshaw 8-0-49-1, Kelly 8.3-0-49-3, Davis G 2-0-6-1
Mt Lawley won

Scarborough v Rockingham-Mandurah
Scarborough
First Innings
Heron c Heal b Parsons 5
Stoinis c Whiteman b Parsons 2
Doropoulos c Coulson b Perera 29
Langer c Heal b Parsons 20
Johnson b Sarsero 0
Coetzee b Senz 108
Nowell run out 22
Hopes c Whiteman b Loveridge 0
Mitchell c Perera b Sarsero 5
Tye not out 27
Branston not out 2
Sundries: 7
Total: 9-227
Fall: 8, 9, 35, 53
Bowling: Parsons 10-0-48-3, Loveridge 10-0-47-1, Sarsero 10-3-42-2, Senz 6-3-32-1, Perera 4-0-18-1, Heal 10-2-40-0

Rockingham-Mandurah
First Innings
Coulson b Branston 0
Sutton c&b Hopes 43
Heal c Tye b Coetzee 18
Staines c Johnson b Branston 0
Whiteman c Johnson b Tye 17
Whiteaker st Johnson b Hopes 16
Perera st Johnson b Hopes 1
Senz c Heron b Hopes 0
Sarsero st Johnson b Mitchell 22
Parsons b Coetzee 0
Loveridge not out 35
Sundries: 9
Total: 162
Fall: 0, 19, 22, 67, 99, 101, 101, 106, 107, 162
Bowling: Branston 5-0-21-2, Coetzee 9-0-48-2, Tye 8-1-31-1, Mitchell 7.4-1-21-1, Doropoulos 5-0-16-0, Hopes 10-1-25-4
Scarborough won

University v Subiaco-Floreat
University
First Innings
Cameron J c Murphy b Serjeant 104
Cameron A c Hansberry b Bolton 24
Paver lbw Monteleone 6
Mangan b Baker 20
Penter M c Branston b Serjeant 14
Evans c Serjeant b Baker 0
Marshall not out 13
Barratt not out 3
Sundries: 15
Total: 6-199
Fall: 59, 85, 161, 174, 174, 189
Bowling: Branston 5-0-17-0, Willey 6-0-25-0, Baker 9-0-42-2, Bolton 6-1-10-1, Hansberry 10-0-49-0, Monteleone 10-1-33-1, Serjeant 4-0-22-2

Subiaco-Floreat
First Innings
Bolton lbw Molinari 4
Malajczuk c Cameron A b Molinari 2
Willey c Marshall b Evans 3
Glew b Penter A 10
Murphy st Marshall b Mangan 42
Hansberry c Marshall b Penter A 17
Monteleone c Penter M b Molinari 34
Serjeant c Marshall b Mangan 2
Townsend c Molinari b Mangan 12
Branston not out 28
Baker not out 2
Sundries: 21
Total: 9-177
Fall: 9, 16, 16, 35, 92, 96, 102, 127, 155
Bowling: Molinari 10-2-25-3, Evans 10-1-42-1, Penter A 10-3-23-2, Cameron J 5-0-36-0, Mangan 10-2-20-3, Penter M 5-1-28-0
University won

Round 12 ladder
Melville 164.86
Scarborough 149.24
Bayswater-Morley 127.57
Perth 126.16
Willetton 121.40
Subiaco-Floreat 117.11
Claremont-Nedlands 116.54
University 115.86
Wanneroo 115.62
Rockingham-Mandurah 108.18
Fremantle 100.01
South Perth 98.30
Joondalup 96.70
Gosnells 85.72
Mt Lawley 84.36
Midland-Guildford 62.77

PERTH
JOHN TOWNSEND

as posted here

past it's used by date ...


I think this bin has had it, near Coles on Albany Highway, well at least people have stopped putting rubbish in it, but I wonder how long it will take to replace ...

Tuesday 27 January 2009

Bikies suspected of nightclub bashing begin trial

as posted here

* Joseph Sapienza
* January 27, 2009 - 3:46PM

Three members of the Gypsy Jokers motorcycle gang who allegedly bashed another man outside a Gosnells nightclub in 2007 began their trial in the WA District Court today.

The men - Dean Alan Adams, Peter Floyd Robinson and Gordon Edwin Rodgers - have been accused of intending to cause harm to as well as endangering the life of Petera Heta Haimona outside the Cactus Nightclub in the early hours of May 12, 2007.

State prosecutor James MacTaggart told the court that each of the accused inflicted several injuries on Mr Haimona by a "combination of kicking and punching" along with various objects such as a wheel brace, club and a piece of wood or metal approximately one metre in length.

"It was a brutal attack which occurred in a short amount of time," he said during his opening address.

"They punched, kicked or otherwise hit him with the objects I described with the intention to cause harm.

"His life, health and safety were likely to have been endangered during the attack."

The prosecution also put forward an alternative charge of grievous bodily harm because of Mr Haimona's injuries.

The court was told the attack occurred outside the nightclub in the car park a little before 4am when Mr Haimona - who was known as "Kiwi Pete" to nightclub staff - went to help out a friend who was involved in a scuffle.

He was later chased by the three accused as he moved up a flight of stairs leading to the club.

Mr MacTaggart said Robinson attempted to strike the victim with a club, but Mr Haimona kicked out at him, causing Robinson to fall down the stairs.

The court heard Rodgers and Adams then struck the victim with various objects.

Adams struck Mr Haimona "several times with a wheel brace to the head and upper body" and was also kicked in the head during the attack.

"It forced Mr Haimona to curl up on the ground to try to protect himself," Mr MacTaggart said.

"Mr Haimona was bleeding profusely from the wounds on his head and suffered bruising to his head and upper body."

He also suffered abrasions and swelling to his left ear, a swollen nose and skin abrasions to the back of his torso.

"The injuries were likely to cause permanent damage," Mr MacTaggart told the court before describing Robinson as the "main participant" in the suspected attack.

"(Also) the appearances of the men were consistent with those on the security footage.

"This was an undoubted attack for which there was no lawful excuse."

Rodgers' lawyer, Gary Massey, told the jury that although there was no denying the injuries suffered by the complainant, "what is in dispute however is whether or not Rodgers did it".

"You must try the case on the evidence and not let any feelings of prejudice and sympathy sway your decision," he said.

Jeremy Scudds - who is representing Adams - reminded the jury the "burden of proof" fell on the prosecution.

"Even reliable witnesses can be wrong," he said.

"The consistency in terms of appearance on the footage is not beyond reasonable doubt.

"It is a bogan's pub.

"There are a lot of goatees, beards and long hair at the Cactus Club - which would suggest many people who go there have very similar appearances."

Defence counsel for Robinson, Helen Prince, also raised doubts about the use of identification as evidence in the trial.

"The problem with identification is that honest people can be mistaken," she said.

He said her client had been at that pub the previous lunchtime.

The court was told he would call on witnesses during the trial to confirm that he was asleep at the time of the suspected attack "after a long day of drinking".

"Robinson's DNA was not found on any weapons the State is referring to," Ms Prince told the court.

"Ten days after the attack, police went to his house and he looked the same.

"Surely he would have been expected to change his appearance had he done it."

The trial, which is set down for a week before Judge Roger Macknay, continues.

as posted here

Day one ..

the following reply was given ...

Thankyou for your enquiry. Council meetings are conducted under the provisions of the City of Gosnells Standing Orders Local Law 2003, a co...